|
Summary of HART activities carried out in Ghana - 2001
Village centered research in the Amasaman sub-district
Numerous studies have previously shown that BU typically afflicts
the young and impoverished rural population. It begins as a painless
nodule but progresses to a more serious ulcerative form. Though
the ulcer often heals spontaneously, extensive scarring, flexion
contractures, and loss of limbs are not uncommon. If death occurs,
it is usually not attributed to the ulcer. Unfortunately, as
Dr. Kingsley Asiedu has pointed out on several occasions, decision-making
bodies of national health programs often neglect diseases that
tend to affect the poor and have a low mortality. HART believes
that socio-economic research directed at estimating the true
burden of BU in the Ga district will provide a better understanding
of the magnitude of this horrible disease, as well as valuable
information for health centers and policy-makers at the national
level. With this in mind, a team of ten HART researchers spent
six weeks in five endemic villages conducting research on the
economic burden, social beliefs, and healing practices associated
with BU in the Amasaman and Obom sub-districts. A brief overview
of their findings is provided in this report.
Education
The goal of the 2001 HART pilot education program in the Amasaman
sub-district was to increase the frequency of reporting and
treatment of the pre-ulcerative forms of BU. To accomplish
this goal, HART implemented a system of education based on
a modified version of the collaborative health education
project between the Ghanaian Ministry of Health, the School
of Medical Sciences at Kumasi and St. George’s Medical
School, London, United Kingdom were taken. First, in an attempt
to increase community awareness of the disease progression
and its consequences, HART organized large group meetings
in each of the 25 villages selected in the pilot program.
The meeting was scheduled after visiting the village several
times to educate the local health worker, and coordinating
a time at which the majority of the village would attend.
Color posters were used to alert the village and in many
cases the health volunteer went door to door to invite families
to the meeting. During each meeting, the community health
volunteer and a member of the HART outreach team presented
information on the disease process and its proper treatment.
Special emphasis was placed on reporting suspicious bumps
and swellings to the local health volunteer and seeking early
treatment.
Although addressing the cause and source of the
disease is difficult given their uncertainty within the
scientific community itself, possible risk factors such as
contact with
marshy areas, neglect of open sores on the upper and lower
limbs, and personal and environmental cleanliness were
discussed. Following the presentation, questions and concerns
from the
community were addressed. Mothers were encouraged to perform
regular full body checks on their children and to report
all suspicious skin lesions to the village health volunteer.
The village was also informed that in the coming weeks,
a team of doctors would be in the area to examine all probable
cases. The village health worker performed follow-up using
the visual aids and BU registry provided during training. Outreach
HART 2001 outreach efforts included a five-week active surveillance
exercise, carried out in 25 villages in the Amasaman and
Obom sub-districts. The exercise was patterned after the
successful Guinea Worm Eradication Program (GWEP) surveillance
model. More often than not however, participants of GWEP
were no longer found in the villages we worked in. Instead,
district mobilization officers were used in their place or
in certain circumstances the village chief appointed a community
member to act as a BU officer. Three major obstacles of passive
surveillance were considered during the development of the
program. First, BU typically occurs in remote areas where
villagers seldom have contact with health centers. In order
to deal with the issue of geographic isolation, the Amasaman
outreach program seeks to simplify reporting procedures.
Under the established surveillance, 25 villages were divided
into three zones. In each zone, a zone leader has been designated
and is responsible for gathering a monthly report from each
of the surrounding villages in the zone.
Finally, once a
month during routine maternity and child-health visits
to each of the zones, Amasaman health center staff will
receive
the complete zone report on suspicious and probable BU
cases. In addition, each village health worker was provided
with
a limited supply of field dressings that could be used
for those unable to travel to Amasaman. Second, community
understanding
of the disease and its healing process is limited which
promotes the belief that it does not have an effective
medical treatment.
To address this misconception, HART developed the pilot
education program as previously mentioned. The outreach
education program
sought to change the way the community felt about the disease
and impress upon them the need to seek early attention
for suspicious skin conditions. Third, because traditional
treatment
is usually the treatment of choice in the village, an effective
surveillance program must take into consideration traditional
beliefs and the healers that provide health services in
the area.
Unfortunately, the current outreach program does
not
adequately address this important detail. To address
this concern, HART conducted a two-week field investigation
traditional management of BU. In the study, surveys of
active and healed
BU cases, traditional healers, and health center staff
from the Amasaman/Obom sub-districts were conducted in
order to
better understand community perceptions and beliefs in
regards to traditional vs. modern treatment of disease
and in particular
BU. This information will be utilized during our 2002
outreach
efforts. Medico-Surgical Mission
HART’s Medico-Surgical mission involved two important
components. First, over a six-day period, a small team of HART
doctors and nurses performed several nodulectomies and provided
pre-surgical triage of over 150 probable cases of BU. During
this time, the team worked at temporary health outposts organized
at Amamorley, Macedonia, and Ayikai Doblo in the Amasaman sub-district.
Several patients were also seen at the Obom sub-district health
center. Additionally, our doctors and nurses provided primary
health services to nearly 150 non-BU patients. At the conclusion
of the mission, HART and LDS Charity (LDSC) co-sponsored a
small health fair at which general community health concerns
were addressed. At the fair, several nurses provided training
to participating healthcare workers and village health volunteers
on proper dressing and cleaning techniques for the ulcerative
condition. Basic field dressing kits including hand woven,
washable “leper bandages” were distributed among
the community health volunteers involved in the outreach program.
Second, a team of HART surgeons and nurses arrived at Amasaman
and selected a number of high priority cases from the triage
list prepared by the medical team. Over the next ten days,
17 patients from this list received treatment. For the purpose
of research currently underway at Brigham Young University
in Provo, Utah; USA, clinical specimens and demographic data
were collected from each of the 17 patients.
Organizational
Throughout the 2001 trip, HART sought to extend the role of
its local Ghanaian Board of Directors in the aforementioned
activities. The local Board of Directors was established
to provide the critical insight, facilitation, and sustained
presence needed for HART to effectively operate in Ghana.
Through the HART International Ghana Board of Directors,
HART sought to create the strategic partnerships that would
allow for its programs to become joint initiatives with other
key collaborators. Greater involvement of the Ghanaian Ministry
of Health was sought, as well as increased participation
with local health care leaders, such as the Department of
Reconstructive Plastic Surgery at the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital.
HART’s ongoing partnership with Latter Day-Saint Charities
[LDSC] was solidified, as LDSC pledged its support of HART
programs in Ghana in upcoming years. Furthermore, Mrs. Theresa
Kufuor, First Lady of Ghana, accepted an invitation to serve
as the Matron of HART International Ghana, which will allow
HART to garner further support and direction as it seeks
to serve her country.
Summary of findings
Role of traditional treatment in the management of the disease.
Of noted interest was the observation that 84% of the cases
claimed to have used some form of traditional treatment in
the management of the disease, suggesting future collaboration
with traditional healers and herbalists within the district
may improve active case surveillance efforts in the area.
BU prevalence rates appear to be higher in the Ga district
than previously believed. In just two weeks, nearly 150 active
operable cases of BU were identified and documented for future
treatment. This high number of cases identified in only a small
number (n=25) of known communities in the Amasaman and Obom
sub-districts seems to suggest that the actual burden is considerably
higher than previously estimated.
Duration of the disease. The duration of BU varies according
to location, age, and treatment type. Most minor cases seem
to heal within the first few months. More serious cases typically
last up to six months and if excessive tissue damage is present
may become chronic lasting years.
Duration in Months |
Number of Cases |
1-3 |
46 |
4-6 |
27 |
7-9 |
2 |
10-12 |
13 |
13-15 |
1 |
16-18 |
4 |
19-21 |
1 |
22-24 |
17 |
> 25 |
17 |
Not given |
45 |
Total |
172 |
Beliefs and Causes of the disease
Villagers are generally
familiar with BU, its progression, and the problems it can
cause. Most people identified BU in its early stages and
sought herbal treatment. Perceived causes of the disease varied
from
community to community. All of these perceptions should be
addressed in developing culturally appropriate education
programs.
Perceived Cause |
# of Responses |
Drinking bad water |
20 |
Bathing in bad water |
11 |
Both drinking and bathing in bad water |
17 |
Cattle |
4 |
Airborne |
13 |
insect bite |
16 |
Witchcraft |
45 |
Spiritual |
9 |
Person to person |
9 |
Genetics |
7 |
Unsure |
31 |
Total |
172 |
Age of patient and body location distribution of
BU
Early
analysis of the affected population supports previous reports
that Buruli Ulcer affects mainly the younger population and
is found mostly on the upper and lower limbs. Particular attention
should be directed to number of ulcers found at joints, as
these tend to be more serious and more prone to contracture
injuries.
Location on Body |
Number of Cases |
Head or neck |
7 |
Stomach or chest |
2 |
Back |
7 |
Buttocks |
7 |
Upper arm |
8 |
Elbow |
9 |
Forearm |
13 |
Hand |
16 |
Thigh |
11 |
Knee |
26 |
Calf |
13 |
Shin |
21 |
Ankle |
15 |
Foot |
12 |
Total |
169 |
Age Distribution |
Female |
Male |
Total |
0-5 years |
8 |
9 |
17 |
6-10 years |
23 |
19 |
42 |
11-15 years |
21 |
32 |
53 |
16-20 years |
16 |
8 |
24 |
21-30 years |
4 |
6 |
10 |
31-40 years |
9 |
2 |
11 |
41+ years |
7 |
8 |
15 |
TOTAL |
88 |
84 |
172 |
Conclusions
Although HART has made tremendous progress in its attempt
to provide a more comprehensive approach to addressing the
gravity of the problems BU presents in the Ga district; there
are several areas of concern that must be addressed prior
to 2002 activities in Ghana. The following are important areas
of concern:
Unfortunately, due to administrative complications at the
hospitals in Amasaman, Nswam and Korle-Bu, the surgeons
were not able
to operate on as many as they had hoped. On previous trips
to Agroyesum and Dunkwa, HART surgeons have been able treat
often up to 60 patients during a ten-day period. This year,
over the same time period, only 17 patients received treatment
from the team.
The free treatment of BU is not free. Although free treatment
of the Buruli Ulcer has been promised according to the
Yamoussoukro Declaration of 1998, this decision has not
been supported.
Often when patients do report to government sponsored health
centers they are asked to pay money for their dressings,
antibiotics and other prescriptions. Both Amasaman and
Korle-Bu were questioned
about the price their patients paid for “free” treatment.
The staff at Amasaman explained that if the clinic does not
have an item in stock, they will give a prescription to the
patient to buy their medicine elsewhere.
This problem may stem from the fact that the clinic does
not receive any supplemental increase in their monthly
budget for
supplies and reimbursement for supplies used to treat
BU are either slow in coming or are not coming at all.
At
Korle-Bu, the staff charges the patient for items needed
for dressings
and dressing changes that may be sought daily in serious
cases
or weekly in minor cases. The average cost for a dressing
change was found to be 20,000 cedis per visit. It has
also been reported
that some of the patients who have gone to both Amasaman
and Korle- Bu for treatment were turned away because
their cases “were
not serious enough” or there was not enough staff or
beds to accommodate them. Surprisingly, several patients were
also turned away because their condition was too serious to
be treated. In order to address these concerns, a careful review
of the treatment cost and hospital referral system should be
made at Amasaman.
Geographic isolation of the population is a major obstacle
to seeking treatment during the early stages of the disease.
Transportation can be costly for many whose average daily
wage is about 10,000 cedi (<1.10 USD). The average cost
of round trip transportation from the villages to Nswam or
Korle-Bu is about 5,000 cedi per person. A limited government
sponsored transit system could be developed to provide weekly
transportation for those seeking outpatient treatment at Amasaman.
Money should not be given directly to the patient for this
expense.
|